Thursday, September 11, 2014

Reading Response: The Truth about Alice by Jennifer Mathieu

Over the summer, I read a book called The Truth about Alice by Jennifer Mathieu.  The Truth about Alice is about a girl named Alice who goes to Healy High School in Texas where apparently everyone knows everything about each other.  According to Elaine O'Dea, Alice slept with two guys at one party.  One of the boys Alice slept with, Brandon the most popular boy at Healy High, died in a car accident while sexting Alice.  After the rumors are spread, Alice is ridiculed by everybody, even by her best friend Kelsie.  The girls' bathroom has a special stall dedicated to Alice stating terrible things about her.  I really enjoyed Jennifer Mathieu's debut novel.  This book has so many amazing qualities to it.  For example, it is written from five different point of views.  Also, Jennifer shows how a rumor can change many relationships.  Finally, Jennifer shows how a rumor can completely change somebody’s life.

          The Truth about Alice is written from five different point of views.  There's Elaine, the most popular girl from Healy High.  Kelsie, Alice's ex-best friend.  Josh, one of the jocks and Brandon's best friend.  Kurt, the nerd.  And finally Alice, the girl who slept with two guys at one party.  We hear everybody's opinion about "Alice's story".  Elaine swears that Alice slept with two guys at her party.  Elaine knows for a fact that Brandon's death was Alice's fault.  She is convinced that Alice is a slut.  Elaine is someone I would never associate myself with.  She boasts about being popular and about treating the nerds like ants.  Also, Josh tells us that he was with Brandon during the car accident, but he survived.  Josh tells us that Brandon's death wasn't Alice's fault, but that Brandon's death was his fault.  Though out the book, I felt bad for him.  He and Brandon had been driving home from Elaine's party after drinking alcohol.  Brandon thought it would be a good idea to call Alice, but Josh didn't.  Josh snatched the phone form Brandon's hands, after he had gotten over the shock Brandon looked back at the road to see a car coming straight at them.  I understand how Josh must've felt.  He was one the one who took Brandon's attention away from the road and yet he was the one who survived the accident.

Jennifer Mathieu really shows how a rumor can change relationships.  For example, Kelsie reveals that she ruined her relationship with Alice because she didn't want her to bring down her own reputation.  Kelsie's personality really annoyed me.  She herself spread rumors about Alice that she knew for a fact weren't true.  Kelsie told everybody that Alice got pregnant and had an abortion.  Little did everyone else know that she was the one who got pregnant and had an abortion.  I can’t imagine someone who would stoop so low as to stop talking to someone because of their reputation.  I think she spread those rumors to conceal her own problems.  Also, Alice and Kurt built a relationship because of all of the rumors.  Kurt had been an outcast for being a nerd, while Alice was an outcast for being the star of terrible rumors.  Kurt began to tutor Alice in math and their relationship grew from there.  They were outcasts together.  I really loved Kurt’s character.  He never paid any attention to the rumors about Alice.  His opinion never changed over Alice until he heard the story directly from her.  I would love to have a friend like Kurt.  Someone who didn’t believe everything they heard and took your word before anybody else’s.

Jennifer Mathieu shows how a rumor can change somebody’s life.  I feel so bad for Alice.  Her entire life changed after an untrue rumor was spread.  Before the rumor, Alice had been well known and liked by everybody.  After the rumor, she was a loser.  Someone nobody wanted to be seen with.  I think Alice was a really strong person.  Even though everyone ridiculed her, she kept her head held up high.  She knew what was true and that was all that mattered.  I think that quality in a person is very important.  I think everybody should have it.  As long as you know what is true and what it false, you shouldn’t care about what others think, believe, or say.

Overall, I really enjoyed this book.  I would definitely recommend it to people who enjoy reading realistic-fiction, teen drama, and young adult novels.  This book will really make you think about how you are pursuing your life and who you associate yourself with.